Packers currently have six retired #'s: Don Hutson (14), Tony Canadeo (3), Bart Starr (15), Ray Nitschke (66), Reggie White (92) and Brett Favre (4). So right there are your top six, IMO - I don't see anyone who doesn't already have their number retired who should be any higher than any of those guys. There may be others who one day will join that group (of retired numbers), but until they do, these are the greatest of the greatest for me.
So of those 6, I put Starr for sure ahead of Favre and Nitschke. White is closer, but I still think Starr wins out. Canadeo and Hutson, it's tougher because they are SOOO long ago - I know Hutson was a totally transcendent player (retired with 99 career TDs when the next closest had 30-ish, basically designed half the routes that WR's run today, plus also had a bunch of INTs as a DB); Canadeo I honestly just don't know enough about.
So Bart is comfortably in the top 3. And to be perfectly honest, five titles in a 7 year span, a 9-1 playoff record, looking at his performances in those playoff games, PLUS the man that he was in every area of life and the ambassador he was for the team for all those years - frankly, when you put it all together, I wouldn't argue in the least if you said he is the greatest Packer of all time.
But not even included in the top 10? BULL.
« Back to index