Great idea and points.

Since they supposedly think Watson will be back for the last half of the season, I would probably include him.

No S Bullard, OL Morgan, DT Brooks?

I don't have a clue how to rank Wicks... route running, A# in tier 1... but hands potential could potentially total negate that.

I'm assuming we're leaving out true rookies who haven't played a down yet.


I think we all agree with LB Cooper's potential to be elite, but I'm not sure he'd be in my tier 1 until he proves he can consistently earn the right to be on the field instead of being healthy on the bench. THAT OR make a tier 0 for Tom to be even higher.

I'm higher in both Walkers than you. I agree with you on which tier, but I just have them higher in the pecking orders of those tiers.


I don't know how Rhyan makes this list... I mean he's not bad... but not good either, just totally average.

In no particular order, LB Walker, S Bullard, WR Watson, OL Morgan and QB Willis should all be listed before Rhyan. Also maybe these guys as well, DE Enagbare, Van Ness, DT Brooks and RB Brooks.

PS: May you be protected when the Willis super fans realize you don't even give him an honorable mention, much less have him in your top 10.