I think you're seriously underrating 2010 Rodgers, who has no run game helping him, and a scheme that puts more pressure on the QB, vs 2025 Love who has a GREAT RB and scheme that takes pressure off the QB. I'd go Rodgers all day...


Also I believe Nelson broke out mid-season, just people didn't realize until the playoffs. He went from never getting even 30 yards, to getting lots of 40+ yard games including a few 60+ yard games... and that was with teams switching their attention to him as the deep threat opening some other guys up underneath, as the 2010 season started with Finley as a focal point, which clearly upset Jennings, then Finely get injured, and they go with a lot of under cut crossing routes after Nelson or TE Quarless cleared the safety by going deep.